Student Conference Explores Corporate Scandals, Crisis Intervention, and Organizational Resilience

JD MBA Students' Association Conference program cover: Corporate Scandal

The 27th Annual Business & Law Conference kicked off with a warm welcome to attendees, as the JD/MBA Students’ Association from Osgoode Hall Law School and Schulich School of Business brought together a diverse audience of students, alumni, academics, and industry professionals. The conference serves as a platform for exploring pressing issues at the crossroads of law, business, and public policy.

This year’s theme, “Corporate Scandal: Crisis Intervention and Organizational Resilience,” delves into the aftermath of corporate scandals that have made global headlines in recent years. From unethical tax consulting in Australia to high-profile price-fixing battles in Canada, the conference aims to dissect the complexities surrounding these scandals and shed light on strategies for crisis intervention and organizational recovery.

The event focuses on key themes, including the creation and maintenance of crisis-resilient organizations, rebuilding post-scandal, and effective management and lawyering amid corporate crises. The expert panelists and Keynote Speaker, Lawrence Ritchie ’86, are expected to provide valuable insights into these critical areas.

Dean Trevor Farrow, addressing the attendees, expressed pride in the high-caliber students who make up York University’s premier JD/MBA program. Recognizing the unique position of these students with a dual education in law and business, Dean Farrow emphasized the importance of understanding the intricate challenges posed by corporate scandals. He highlighted the role of legal and business professionals in upholding justice, transparency, and accountability.

Encouraging active participation in discussions, Dean Farrow urged attendees to absorb the knowledge shared by distinguished speakers and collaborate with peers to deepen their understanding of corporate law and governance. He emphasized that the legal profession goes beyond interpreting statutes, calling on attendees to safeguard the principles that underpin society.

In closing, Dean Farrow expressed confidence that the conference would equip students with a heightened awareness of the challenges and complexities in the corporate and legal spheres. He encouraged them to seize the opportunity to expand their horizons, challenge their perspectives, and emerge as advocates for justice and ethical conduc

Osgoode Professor Suzanne Chiodo Appointed to Major Civil Justice Reform Initiative

Suzanne Chiodo

An Osgoode assistant professor has just been appointed to a working group that will be transforming civil justice in Ontario. Suzanne Chiodo is the only academic member of the Civil Rules Review Working Group, an initiative announced earlier this week by Attorney General Doug Downey and Chief Justice Morawetz of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice.

The Working Group will be reviewing the Rules of Civil Procedure, which govern civil non-family proceedings before the Ontario Superior Court. It will identify issues and develop proposals for reforming the Rules to make civil court processes more efficient, affordable, and accessible. Other members of the Working Group include judges and members of the private and public bar. The aim of the initiative is to increase access to justice; reduce cost, delay, and complexity; maximize the use of court resources; and leverage technical solutions.

“I am very proud to be the academic member of this committee”, said Professor Chiodo. “It’s exciting to be a part of improving access to civil justice in Ontario.”

The Working Group will begin consultations with civil justice system stakeholders in early 2024.

March 13 Osgoode conference to examine the impact of AI on all areas of the law

Stylized image of human brain symbolizing artificial intelligence

Please visit the conference webpage for a detailed program and registration.

It could be the biggest thing to hit the legal profession since the constitution.

Leading legal thinkers from Osgoode and beyond will gather to assess the seismic impact of artificial intelligence on the law during a special conference March 13 sponsored by the Osgoode-based Nathanson Centre on Transnational Human Rights, Crime and Security.

The event, titled Artificial Intelligence and the Law: New Challenges and Possibilities for Fundamental Human Rights and Security, will take place at the Helliwell Centre at Osgoode from noon until 6:15 p.m. on March 13. Stay tuned for details on registration and the full agenda.

“I am delighted that this incredibly important discussion is being hosted at Osgoode Hall Law School,” said Dean Trevor Farrow.

“Academics, lawyers, policymakers and the public are already heavily influenced by and reliant upon AI,” he added. “Osgoode very much sees itself at the centre of these discussions and innovations.”

By bringing together researchers with AI expertise across various fields of practice, conference speakers and attendees will also be able to engage with larger questions about law’s role in the regulation of emerging technologies, legal neutrality, ethics, and professional responsibility, said Associate Dean (Research and Institutional Relations) Carys Craig, who will speak on AI and copyright.

“I’m very excited about this conference,” she said. “Osgoode is known for its thought leadership and critical, interdisciplinary thinking, which is exactly what is needed as Canada grapples with the rapid acceleration of AI across almost every facet of society.”

The featured speakers will also include Professor Barnali Choudhury, director of the Nathanson Centre.

“Although AI offers numerous opportunities to society, it also poses risks, particularly in relation to human rights and security,” she noted. “Lawyers should be well versed in these risks to ensure that AI use aligns with legal standards.”

The conference’s comprehensive examination of artificial intelligence will include the growing use of generative AI, which powers tools like ChatGPT, said Professor Valerio De Stefano, a co-organizer of the event and a panellist who will address today’s challenging issues around artificial intelligence and work.

“The law will have to react to a lot of the challenges that arise from artificial intelligence in order for society to thrive on the opportunities that AI offers,” he noted.

De Stefano said that almost no area of the law will be left untouched, including criminal law, copyright law, labour law and tax law. Conference speakers will also dig into the implications of AI for legal ethics, legal practice and legal education.

“It’s extremely important that lawyers, both academics and practitioners, start discussing how to react to all these new things that are coming out of the AI landscape – and this is the opportunity to do that,” he added. “There’s a lot of people at Osgoode that do top-notch, groundbreaking research on law and technology.”

Other speakers will include Professor Jonathon Penney, who will examine whether AI safety standards are really safe, and Professor Allan Hutchinson, who will discuss “AI and law’s multiplicity.” Rounding out the list of Osgoode experts are Professor Sean Rehaag, PhD student Alexandra Scott and Osgoode PhD alumnus Jake Okechukwu Effoduh, now a law professor at Toronto Metropolitan University.

In the afternoon, De Stefano will chair a roundtable discussion on artificial intelligence, due process and legal ethics. Panellists will include Osgoode Dean Farrow, Professor Patricia McMahon, Professor Richard Haigh, Glenn Stuart, the executive director of professional regulation for the Law Society of Ontario, and Professor Amy Salyzyn of the University of Ottawa Faculty of Law.

CLASP legal team saves family of York student from deportation in last-minute court reprieve

Photo of Osgoode students Brandon Jeffrey Jang (left) and Emma Sandri outside the CLASP office at Osgoode
CLASP students Brandon Jeffrey Jang (left) and Emma Sandri

With only 11 hours to spare, student lawyers with Osgoode’s Community & Legal Aid Services Program (CLASP) have saved the parents of a York University student from family breakup and deportation to Colombia, where they faced potential danger or even death.

When 2L student Brandon Jeffrey Jang and 3L student Emma Sandri learned on Dec. 18 that the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) had ordered the parents to board a Colombia-bound plane in Toronto on Jan. 18, they worked full out over the Christmas break to prepare about 1,000 pages of legal submissions to stop the deportation. Their request was initially denied by the CBSA, so they filed two supporting applications with the Federal Court, under the supervision of CLASP review counsel Subodh Bharati.

On Jan. 17th, they appeared in person before a Federal Court judge in Toronto to make their case for the family, which has lived in Canada since 2009. The couple’s adult son is a student in York’s School of Kinesiology & Health Science and their daughter is set to graduate from Queen’s University and plans to study medicine. The son and daughter, who already have permanent residency status in Canada, faced being separated from their parents if the deportation had gone ahead as scheduled. The family breakup also threatened their academic careers.

The family expressed their gratitude in an emotional email.

“Thank you very much for all the effort that you put in our case,” the mother wrote. “I don’t have enough words to express what I feel right now and to say thank you. You are the best lawyers that Toronto has. Gracias, amigos! God bless you!”

Their joy was shared by the CLASP team.

“We were just so happy,” said Jang about hearing news of the successful stay application. “We’ve built a close connection with the family and we’ve all worked extremely hard on this case.

“That’s the amazing part about CLASP,” he added, “is that we’re able to take on these very unique, complicated cases that have a tremendous impact on people’s lives.”

Jang said the experience has confirmed his desire to pursue a career in immigration law – and this summer he will work for Toronto immigration law firm Green and Spiegel LLP.

Sandri said that preparing hundreds of pages of court applications in a month was a tremendous challenge, but learning that the family can stay in Canada as a result of their efforts was a huge relief and incredibly rewarding.

“It was difficult in terms of wanting to put out our best work in such a limited time span,” she explained, “and we really felt the pressure of the fact these people’s lives were possibly at stake.”

As they waited for the court decision, she added, “we both couldn’t sleep because we were thinking about what’s going to happen to this family and we were really stressing about that.”

Bharati said the condensed time frame and the last-minute court reprieve made the case more intense than many others that CLASP students have worked on. “This one was even more last minute,” he explained, “because it was hours before their deportation flight.”

In the wake of the court decision, Bharati said, the parents can now obtain work permits while they wait for the Federal Court to hear judicial reviews of previous decisions that rejected their applications for permanent residency status on humanitarian and compassionate grounds.

The father became a target of the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia (FARC) in the early 1990s when he became a candidate for the country’s Liberal Party, actively working to prevent youth from joining the paramilitary organization. After numerous threats and the suspected murder of his nephew by FARC members, the family fled to the United States. When they returned to Colombia seven years later, thinking it was safe, the mother was brutally raped and they fled again, eventually making their way to Canada. With the Colombian peace process currently faltering and FARC still a viable force, the family believes their safety could still be threatened if they return to the country.

In Canada, the parents have become actively involved in their Toronto community, volunteering during the pandemic, for example, to deliver food to house-bound, immune-compromised residents.

With the students’ time at CLASP nearing an end, Jang and Sandri expressed special appreciation for Bharati’s guidance and trust.

“All of our experiences at the clinic leading up to this case prepared us for the uphill battle we confronted when fighting for this family,” said Jang. “The result was a total team effort on everybody’s part and it was all worth it.”

As bankruptcies rise, legal remedies remain inaccessible to many, says Prof. Stephanie Ben-Ishai on The Current

Photo of Stephanie Ben Ishai
Professor Stephanie Ben-Ishai

Community Message from the Dean

January 19, 2024

Dear Osgoode Community:

I write with respect to public expression and the communication of ideas in the context of our intellectually robust, respectful, diverse and inclusive law school community.

In line with previous statements from York University, as well as previous statements, comments and actions from me and my leadership team, we continue to strongly denounce any forms of hate or violence, particularly in an environment where we continue to see increased evidence of antisemitism, Islamophobia, anti-Arab and other forms of hate and violent speech in public discourse.

As we have also consistently stated and in line with York rules and policies, the important rights and privileges of free speech, free association and academic freedom are central to modern universities and cornerstones of democracy, and they need to be robustly valued and protected at all times, both in times of peace and in times of conflict. All of us at the University and beyond depend on those rights and privileges.

At the same time, academic freedom does not include freedom from critique. By the very nature and purpose of the privilege of academic freedom, civil yet robust critique must not only be tolerated but welcomed in the spirit of true intellectual exchange.

As part of our robust commitment to academic freedom and critique, it should also be clearly understood that the communications of any individual at the University – including via media, social media and other public comments and published statements – should never be taken to reflect the views or values of other individuals or of the University. By the very nature of a university in our society, they cannot.

The Osgoode senior leadership team and I, together with our York leadership colleagues, are working continuously to support our students, staff, faculty and alumni. I am regularly meeting with members of our community to listen, learn, and provide information and support. As everyone knows, there are vastly different views and feelings about current matters, from various perspectives and within and between different communities. Our job as members of senior university leadership is to care for and do our best to attend to the learning needs, safety and well-being of our students and all members of our community, while at the same time providing a space for those community members to explore and express ideas, including ideas that others may disagree with or, further, find objectionable. At times, this balance is difficult to maintain; however, it is imperative as a university to make best efforts to do so. Otherwise, the very nature of a university, as a core location for the development and critique of ideas in the service of human creativity, wisdom, empathy and innovation, will be irreparably jeopardized.

As a reminder, the University is increasing resources to provide care and support for students, staff and faculty who are struggling. Information is posted on the Well-being Resources | York University website.

I call on all Osgoode community members and friends, as we engage in the very challenging yet important exploration of ideas in the service of our common future, to do so in respectful, civil and empathetic ways. Doing so is always important, particularly at this time when so many members of our community and others are experiencing feelings of stress, anxiety, fear and grief.

Thank you.

Trevor CW Farrow, PhD
Dean & Professor, Osgoode Hall Law School at York University

Osgoode leads Ontario in student applications for third year running

Photo of Class of 2026
Osgoode’s Class of 2026

For the third consecutive year, Osgoode Hall Law School has attracted more applications for its JD program than any other law school in Ontario.

According to recently released statistics from the Ontario Law School Application Service, a division of the Ontario University Application Centre in Guelph, Ont., Osgoode received 2,867 applications in 2023 for its 2024-2025 first-year class of approximately 300 students.

“I think one powerful thing that our admissions numbers show, it is that we are highly desired, highly sought after,” said Manager, Admissions & Student Financial Services Marcos Ramos Jr.

“But also,” he added, “when you look at our numbers closely, we have one of the most, if not the most diverse class of students within Canada.”

That impressive diversity, he said, is a reflection of the law school’s longstanding holistic admissions policy and a determined effort by its recruiters to create Canada’s most diverse law school. Law students educated in that environment simply become better lawyers, said Ramos Jr.

“Academics are essential,” he noted, “but what makes an excellent lawyer is your social skills, right? And we’re bringing to students an understanding of different walks of life – be it class, race, creed, so on and so forth.”

In recruiting students for Osgoode, he noted, the law school’s recruiters look beyond strong academic skills to each applicant’s life story and passions.

“Show me the passion!” explained Ramos Jr. “Show me how you want to contribute.”

Canada’s first Sikh law students’ group at Osgoode is working to create a national network

Photo of Osgoode Sikh Students' Association Co-Presidents Tripat Kaur Sandhu (left) and Dalraj Gill in Gowling's Hall
OSSA co-presidents Tripat Kaur Sandhu (left) and Dalraj Singh Gill

Members of the fledgling Osgoode Sikh Students’ Association (OSSA) are playing a key role in bringing Sikh law students together at law schools across Canada.

The organization, which was launched in the summer of 2022, was the first of its kind in the country and will play an important role in improving members’ law school experience, said co-president Dalraj Singh Gill, a 2025 candidate in the JD/MBA program.

“The feeling of community in law school can make or break a student’s experience,” he said, “and allowing a Sikh student to interact and work with other Sikh students allows them to share experiences and memories that resonate amongst the group.”

3L student and co-president Tripat Kaur Sandhu and Karen Kaur Randhawa ’23 took the lead in establishing OSSA in 2022. Sandhu, Randhawa and Gill hope the initiative will enrich not only Sikh students at the law school, but the wider Osgoode community, the legal profession at large, and Sikh law students across Canada.

Gill said the organization is helping Sikh law students to remain rooted in the central principles of the Sikh faith, including the pursuit of justice and standing against oppression – ideals that are also relevant to the practice of law.

In addition, members hope the organization, through its various events and activities, will help improve understanding of the Sikh community at Osgoode and will provide a platform to advocate for Sikh issues and other racialized and minority communities at Osgoode.

“Our goal, among others,” said Gill, “is to tackle systemic barriers that prevent Sikh students and persons of colour from accessing the legal profession.”

From their beginnings with OSSA, Sandhu, Randhawa and Gill have actively reached out to Sikh law students across Canada, supporting them in their efforts to launch chapters at their own universities. Sikh law students’ associations followed at the University of Ottawa in January of 2023, Toronto Metropolitan University in February of 2023, the University of Windsor in May of 2023, Thompson Rivers University in the summer of 2023, and Queens University in the fall of 2023. For 2024, an SSA chapter is being eyed at the University of Toronto Faculty of Law.

“We are also hoping to get in touch with B.C. law schools,” said Gill, “and then later expand across to law schools in Manitoba and Saskatchewan and at Dalhousie in Nova Scotia.”

The chapters are not officially affiliated with the Canadian Association of Sikh Lawyers. But Gill said Sikh law students’ groups already established hope to create a Canada-wide network that will extend to alumni groups and professionals who have already established themselves in the legal field. A longer-term goal is to eventually host a national conference involving all SSA chapters.

Last year, the Osgoode Legal & Literary Society presented OSSA with its annual Student Club for Community Building Award.

Coming January 17: On-campus clothing drive sponsored by Osgoode Venture Capital Law Society

Photo of Osgoode Venture Capital Law Society executive members and clothing drive co-organizers Emma Kirwin (left) and Yianni Patiniotis.
OVCLS exec members Emma Kirwin (left) and Yianni Patiniotis.

It’s a clothing conundrum: In competitive careers like law, first impressions can be last impressions if prospects don’t present a professional image.

But for some law students, having the appropriate clothing for on-campus interviews or other formal occasions is not always a luxury they can afford.

That’s why the Osgoode Venture Capital Law Society (OVCLS) is holding its first-ever clothing drive in the Goodmans LLP Junior Common Room (JCR) on the first floor of the Ignat Kaneff Building on Jan. 17 from noon to 2 p.m.

“Outside of the financial burden associated with attending law school, interviewing and recruitment periods also bear less obvious but equally burdensome costs associated with the process,” said 2L student Emma Kirwin, director of communications for the OVCLS.

“The cost of formal business attire can create an additional financial barrier that often goes unacknowledged,” she added. “Alleviating this burden can help students feel more confident, prepared and less stressed during an already stressful and arduous period.”

Yianni Patiniotis, a second-year student in the JD-MBA program and the co-director of external relations for OVCLS, said the organization hopes the inaugural clothing drive will become an annual event that involves other Osgoode student clubs.

“During the recruit and at other times when we’ve been in corporate business settings, we’ve realized how fortunate we were to not have to stress too much about the business attire that we were required to wear,” said Patiniotis.

“If anything,” he added, “we had options to choose from. But we recognized that not all our peers and colleagues have that luxury.”

OVCLS is seeking donations of lightly used suit jackets, dress pants, dress shirts, belts, ties, dress socks and shoes, including heels or flats for women.

The organizers plan to donate the clothing collected to Dress for Success Toronto and Suits Me Fine at Toronto’s Centre for Addiction and Mental Health (CAMH). Osgoode students who need business attire will need to access it through those charities.

Brilliant legacy of former dean Peter Hogg celebrated by top judges and legal scholars

Photo of Supreme Court of Canada Justices Andromache Karakatsanis (left), Sheilah Martin and Mahmud Jamal sitting on a panel at an Osgoode conference Jan. 10, 2024, celebrating the legacy of former dean Peter W. Hogg.
Supreme Court of Canada Justices Andromache Karakatsanis (left), Sheilah Martin and Mahmud Jamal at the Jan. 10 conference celebrating the legacy of former dean Peter W. Hogg.

He changed laws, he changed lives and, at times, he helped change the course of Canadian history.

The brilliant and multi-dimensional legacy of former Osgoode dean and professor Peter W. Hogg was celebrated Jan. 10 during a day-long conference that brought together some of Canada’s brightest legal luminaries, including three sitting Supreme Court of Canada justices, three current judges of the Ontario  Court of Appeal, six former Osgoode deans and other leading legal thinkers from Canada and abroad. The event took place online and in-person at Osgoode’s downtown campus.

In sometimes touching personal reflections, speaker after speaker shared stories of Hogg’s fundamental influence on their careers, the impact of his legendary textbooks, his masterful teaching and prodigious courtroom achievements, and his essential kindness as a person and proud family man. In perhaps his most important roles, he was husband to Fran and father to Anne and David.

Hogg, who joined Osgoode’s faculty in 1970 and served as dean of the law school from 1998 to 2003, died at the age of 80 in February 2020. Fran died two weeks later. After leaving Osgoode in 2003, he served as scholar in residence in the Toronto office of law firm Blake, Cassels & Graydon LLP.

In opening remarks, Dean Trevor Farrow marvelled at how Hogg, a native New Zealander, became his adopted country’s leading authority on Canadian constitutional law. On his arrival at Osgoode in 1970, he said, then-dean Gerald Le Dain thrust two of the most unpopular courses on the neophyte faculty member: constitutional law and tax law. Using his classroom notes, Hogg later wrote his authoritative textbook, Constitutional Law of Canada (Thomson Carswell, 2007), which was first published in 1977. Now in its fifth edition, the book has been cited well over 200 times in Supreme Court of Canada decisions – more than any other source. His other texts, Liability of the Crown (Carswell, 2011), based on his PhD thesis, and Principles of Canadian Income Tax Law (Carswell, 2022), are equally respected.

Hogg also provided invaluable counsel to clients on countless legal questions and cases – some of them of historical importance. In the 1990s, he advised Yukon First Nations in self-government negotiations with the federal and Yukon governments, helping them to win unprecedented sovereignty over their traditional territory. In 2004, in what he looked back on as one of his proudest achievements, he was lead counsel for the Canadian government in the Supreme Court of Canada’s same-sex marriage reference. And in 2008, he advised Gov. Gen. Michaëlle Jean during the prorogation crisis involving the Conservative government of then prime minister Stephen Harper.

In his Supreme Court appearances, Hogg was like a chess master, eagerly facing down nine opponents and defeating them all, said former Osgoode dean and Ontario Court of Appeal Justice Patrick Monahan, borrowing from an observation by former Supreme Court of Canada justice Ian Binnie. Justice Monahan described him as the most influential Canadian lawyer of the past half-century.

But Hogg was first and foremost a consummate teacher who was lauded and loved for his clarity and kindness. His student reviews in course evaluations were consistently “astonishing,” said former dean and Ontario Court of Appeal Justice James MacPherson.

In the classroom, said Osgoode alumnus and Chief Justice of Ontario Michael Tulloch, “It was impossible not to be transfixed by his brilliance, his humility and his ability to simplify complex areas of the law.

“He answered every question carefully and reflectively,” added Justice Tulloch. “Everyone was made to feel important. All the while, he did it with a dry wit and the embodiment of decency.”

Like most students, Osgoode alumna and Supreme Court of Canada Justice Andromache Karakatsanis said she became a diehard fan of Hogg’s after taking his first-year constitutional law course. After that, she signed up for every course he taught.

“Everything he started to teach, I took, and I learned that every area of the law can be fascinating,” she said during the panel session featuring Justice Karakatsanis and her Supreme Court of Canada colleagues Justice Sheilah Martin and Justice Mahmud Jamal.

“He really modelled intellectual curiosity,” she added. “That’s what makes the law to this day so deeply and enduringly important and interesting.”

In a lighter moment, former chief prosecutor of the International Criminal Court and former Supreme Court of Canada justice Louise Arbour remembered being intimidated by Hogg’s reputation when she joined Osgoode’s faculty in 1974 and noticing his New Zealand accent.

“I can remember our first conversation and I thought, ‘Oh my God, I’m not going to make it,’” she recalled. “But then I thought, ‘Well, maybe he’s not going to make it either.’”

In the end, however, Hogg’s influence helped inspire the future course of her career, she said. “I’m absolutely convinced that he was the original cause of the development of my career into the judiciary,” she told the audience.

Several speakers also shared how Hogg played an instrumental role in launching and shaping their own careers in the law.

Osgoode Professor Jinyan Li, who is now a co-author of Hogg’s tax law text, remembered coming to Canada from China in 1985 and joining the Osgoode faculty as a young scholar and mother in 1999, when Hogg was dean. Soon after, he invited her to join him in writing a new edition of Principles of Canadian Income Tax Law.

“When I got the trust of the great Peter, it was such a validation of my potential,” she said. “I used the freedom he gave me liberally and he never complained. The only thing he said to me at one point was, ‘You have to make it simpler.’

“I became a better writer and also a better teacher, but most importantly I became a better citizen,” she added. “Peter has meant so much to me and I’m very happy I’m part of today’s event.”